FOEDUS · Post-ASI Normative Ledger
General research reference only. Not legal advice, military JAG interpretation, or regulatory certification.
Subdomain target: foedus.dioptra.risconlabs.com | override_authority: H-00-ONLY-SIGNED | S-PUB | S-EXT: 0 | S-SIGN: null
Eight Immutable Circuit Breakers (CB-001..008) & Live Sandbox
Live Circuit-Breaker Evaluator (auto_executed = 0)
HOLD| ID | Rule | Condition | Action | Lock | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CB-001 | NO_LIVE_TARGETING_OR_FIRE_CONTROL | input.contains_forbidden_field == true | EXIT_ERR_FORBIDDEN_FIELD | enabled: true (locked) | Reject any real WGS84 geographic coordinates, live target IDs, kill-chain, or fire-control fields. |
| CB-002 | HUMAN_VERIFICATION_BOTTLENECK_EXCEEDED | metrics.verification_bottleneck_ratio > 1.0 | HALT_BREACH | enabled: true (locked) | Halt and queue recommendations whenever ASI proposal load exceeds human audit capacity (VBR > 1.0). |
| CB-003 | HUMAN_TIME_TO_INTERVENE_NEGATIVE | metrics.time_to_intervene_s < 0.0 | HALT_BREACH | enabled: true (locked) | Trigger HALT_BREACH when human intervention margin drops below zero seconds. |
| CB-004 | EPISTEMIC_SENSOR_CONFLICT_DETECTED | epistemic.conflict_ratio >= 0.5 || epistemic.physics_violation == true | HALT_BREACH | enabled: true (locked) | Freeze recommendations when multi-sensor disagreement reaches 50% or physical invariants fail. |
| CB-005 | ACTIVE_STREAM_QUORUM_INSUFFICIENT | epistemic.active_stream_count < 2 | INCONCLUSIVE_DATA_GAP | enabled: true (locked) | Enforce WSTiger Confluence: absent or jammed streams never imply safety; < 2 active streams yields INCONCLUSIVE_DATA_GAP. |
| CB-006 | ROBOT_HUMAN_SPAN_OF_CONTROL_BREACH | metrics.active_robots_per_operator > limits.max_span_of_control | REQUIRES_HUMAN_AUDIT | enabled: true (locked) | Flag REQUIRES_HUMAN_AUDIT when active robotic fleet exceeds safe per-operator supervision ceiling. |
| CB-007 | WILSON_QUORUM_UNMET | gates.vc_r04_n_runs < 4 || gates.vc_r04_wilson_lower_95 < 0.5 | HOLD | enabled: true (locked) | Block evidence promotion when sample size n < 4 or Wilson 95% lower bound is below 0.50. |
| CB-008 | NON_FINITE_OR_MISSING_PROVENANCE | gates.vc_r02_finite_pass == false || provenance.field_tests != 0 | EXIT_ERR_FINITE | enabled: true (locked) | Fail closed on NaN, Infinity, null, or corrupted dry-lab provenance tags. |
Eight Fixed Reading Axes (PRO SE Lineage)
| Axis | Name | Mandatory Textual Question |
|---|---|---|
| AX-01 | Scope & Jurisdiction | Which peacetime, wartime, dual-use, autonomous, or R&D stages are bound by the text? |
| AX-02 | Human Accountability | How does the text affirm that legal and moral responsibility cannot transfer to machines? |
| AX-03 | Pre-Deployment V&V | What legal review, software assurance level, and predictability verification are required before deployment? |
| AX-04 | Distinction & Proportionality | Where does the text draw automation limits on distinction and proportionality judgments? |
| AX-05 | Intervention & Halt Right | Does the text mandate immediate physical or procedural halt and disengage controls for humans? |
| AX-06 | Tempo & Delegation Ceiling | What tempo or delegation limits guard meaningful human control? |
| AX-07 | Auditability & Traceability | Which logs, audit trails, and evidentiary records must be retained for post-incident review? |
| AX-08 | Regulatory Gap & Watch | Which swarm, robotic-attrition, or AGI/ASI gaps remain unaddressed or under active revision? |
Ten Pinned Public Normative Records (FOE-001..FOE-010)
| ID | Record, Pinned Excerpt & Key Axes | Lock Status | Excerpt SHA-256 |
|---|---|---|---|
| FOE-001 |
Geneva Convention Additional Protocol I, Article 36 (1977)
In the study, development, acquisition or adoption of a new weapon, means or method of warfare, a High Contracting Party is under an obligation to determine whether its employment would, in some or all circumstances, be prohibited by this Protocol or by any other rule of international law applicable to the High Contracting Party. AX-02: Obligation rests directly on High Contracting Parties (human state authorities). | AX-08: Silent on continuous self-modifying AGI/ASI software post-acquisition. |
VERBATIM_LOCKED | 0782d48ffafe9e8d source |
| FOE-002 |
Geneva Convention Additional Protocol I, Articles 48 & 51(5)(b)
In order to ensure respect for and protection of the civilian population and civilian objects, the Parties to the conflict shall at all times distinguish between the civilian population and combatants and between civilian objects and military objectives. AX-02: Parties and human commanders bear non-delegable legal obligation. | AX-08: Does not define verification bounds against synthetic multi-sensor epistemic spoofing. |
VERBATIM_LOCKED | c354a68acd1296af source |
| FOE-003 |
US DoD Directive 3000.09 (2023 Update): Autonomy in Weapon Systems
Autonomous and semi-autonomous weapon systems shall be designed to allow commanders and operators to exercise appropriate levels of human judgment over the use of force. AX-02: Commanders and operators retain accountable human judgment over use of force. | AX-08: Phrase 'appropriate levels of human judgment' lacks quantitative VBR or TTI thresholds for ASI speed. |
VERBATIM_LOCKED | b6610924665afd60 source |
| FOE-004 |
MIL-STD-882E: Department of Defense Standard Practice for System Safety
System safety risk assessment categorizes hazards by severity and probability, assigning Software Control Categories and Levels of Rigor for safety-critical software functions. AX-02: Named risk acceptance authorities must sign off residual hazard categories. | AX-08: Classical probabilistic hazard matrices under-specify adversarial AGI/ASI distributional shift. |
SUMMARY_PENDING_VERBATIM | cc99a1e23d6ec242 source |
| FOE-005 |
RTCA DO-178C: Software Considerations in Airborne Systems and Equipment Certification
Design Assurance Level A (DAL-A) requires bidirectional traceability from requirements to object code and Modified Condition/Decision Coverage (MC/DC) structural verification. AX-02: Independent verification authority and Designated Engineering Representative sign-off. | AX-08: Online learning and LLM/ASI reasoning fall outside classical DO-178C deterministic certification. |
SUMMARY_PENDING_VERBATIM | 61695e86196b438c source |
| FOE-006 |
UN GGE on LAWS: 11 Guiding Principles (2019)
Human responsibility for decisions on the use of weapons systems must be retained since accountability cannot be transferred to machines. AX-02: Principle (b): accountability cannot be transferred to machines. | AX-08: Non-binding consensus principles; no binding treaty verification mechanism or ASI tempo cap. |
VERBATIM_LOCKED | 160a1316c0647ed7 source |
| FOE-007 |
NATO STANAG 4586 & STANAG 4671 (UAV Interoperability & Airworthiness)
Defines Levels of Interoperability (LOI 1 to 5), explicit vehicle control handover protocols, and deterministic lost-link fail-safe contingencies for unmanned aircraft systems. AX-02: Explicit single-authority control handover preventing dual-command ambiguity. | AX-08: Designed for individual UAVs; swarm-scale 1:N control and fiber-optic micro-UAVs exceed legacy assumptions. |
SUMMARY_PENDING_VERBATIM | 7f7a476131ee15cb source |
| FOE-008 |
EU AI Act (Regulation (EU) 2024/1689), Article 2(3) & Recital 24
This Regulation does not apply to AI systems where and in so far as they are placed on the market, put into service, or used with or without modification exclusively for military, defence or national security purposes, regardless of the type of entity carrying out those activities. AX-02: High-risk dual-use providers retain statutory conformity and human-oversight obligations. | AX-08: Sharp legal seam when commercial foundation/AGI models are adapted into defense workflows. |
VERBATIM_LOCKED | 013bd1b6d4b637ba source |
| FOE-009 |
Wassenaar Arrangement Dual-Use Classification Principles (Public Categories)
Public classification boundaries distinguish general academic/open physical equations from controlled technical data, manufacturing blueprints, and guidance firmware. AX-02: Institutional compliance officer responsibility for export-control screening. | AX-08: Rapid convergence of consumer FPV drones and commercial robotics blurs dual-use threshold lists. |
SUMMARY_PENDING_VERBATIM | 81693c208aebad5f source |
| FOE-010 |
RISCON Labs Human ASI Auditor Charter (L0-L6 Boundary Covenant)
ASI carries the answers. The boundary of the question and final judgment remains with a human auditor. AX-02: Single Human Auditor (H-00) holds exclusive final release, refutation, and override authority. | AX-08: Explicitly acknowledges ASI epistemic horizon: human models cannot predict unknown superhuman emergence, so Fail-Closed halt is the minimum safety brake. |
VERBATIM_LOCKED | 0a27647a819d5c53 source |
Regulatory Watch List (W-01..W-03)
| ID | Topic | Affected Axes | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| W-01 | UN GGE on LAWS 2026 Rolling Text on Autonomous Systems | AX-02, AX-05, AX-08 | MONITORING_PUBLIC_DRAFT |
| W-02 | DoD 3000.09 AI/LLM Evaluation Annex Updates | AX-03, AX-06, AX-08 | MONITORING_PUBLIC_DRAFT |
| W-03 | NATO STANAG Swarm Interoperability Working Group | AX-05, AX-07, AX-08 | MONITORING_PUBLIC_DRAFT |
FOEDUS Calculators & Assigned AI Roles (R-12..R-14)
| ID | Name | Closed-Form Formula | Default Value (IEEE-754 Hex) | Limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CALC-25 | Human Verification Bottleneck (VBR) | VBR = (lambda_asi * (T_aud / 60)) / A_hum | 1.25000 ratio (0x3ff4000000000000) | VBR > 1.0 trips CB-002 HALT_BREACH; excess proposals queue with auto_executed = 0. |
| CALC-29 | Cumulative False-Alarm Fatigue | P_fa_cum = 1 - det_exp_f64(-lambda_fa * T) | 0.393469 prob (0x3fd92e9a0720d3ec) | Poisson independent false-alarm assumption using deterministic polynomial exp. |
| CALC-30 | Circuit-Breaker Halt Safety Margin | M_cb = T_irreversible - (t_detect + t_halt) | 3.50000 s (0x400c000000000000) | Excludes physical actuator inertia; requires hardware-level verification outside dry lab. |
| CALC-32 | ASI Verification Cost Asymmetry | V_asym = C_human_audit_per_dec / C_asi_gen_per_dec | 9000.00 x (0x40c1940000000000) | Raw unit-cost ratio; excludes automated audit-assist compression. |
| Role ID | Title | Mission | Required Outputs |
|---|---|---|---|
| R-12 (AI) | IHL & RoE Textualist | Read Geneva AP I, DoD 3000.09, MIL-STD-882E, DO-178C, and UN GGE texts along 8 fixed axes with Verbatim Lock. | eight_axis_norm_ledger, verbatim_lock_hashes, regulatory_watch_list |
| R-13 (AI) | ASI Deterrence & Stability Researcher | Document escalation boundary conditions and refutation criteria under post-ASI decision speed. | stability_boundary_atlas, refutation_conditions, escalation_horizon_notes |
| R-14 (AI) | Constitutional Circuit-Breaker Auditor | Maintain declarative halt rules (CB-001..CB-008) locking outputs to non-executing states on violation. | circuit_breaker_eval_report, halt_audit_trail, refutation_conditions |